Honda Car Forum

When driving at highway speeds, our '06 Odyssey produces a wierd sonic
"thumping" sensation when the sliding door windows down (even just
partly, in my experience) while the drv/pass windows are up? Lowering
the front windows or raising the sliding door windows makes the
thumping go stop. Anyone else notice this?

aulttim wrote:
>
> When driving at highway speeds, our '06 Odyssey produces a wierd sonic
> "thumping" sensation when the sliding door windows down (even just
> partly, in my experience) while the drv/pass windows are up? Lowering
> the front windows or raising the sliding door windows makes the
> thumping go stop. Anyone else notice this?

--------------------------------------

I think the technical term is 'POP BOTTLE EFFECT' and it happens on LOTS
of vehicles that are fairly air-tight.

'Curly'

On 17 Jun 2006 14:44:23 -0700, "aulttim" <aulttim@gmail.com> wrote:

>When driving at highway speeds, our '06 Odyssey produces a wierd sonic
>"thumping" sensation when the sliding door windows down (even just
>partly, in my experience) while the drv/pass windows are up? Lowering
>the front windows or raising the sliding door windows makes the
>thumping go stop. Anyone else notice this?


1) Get a coke bottle.
2) empty it (down mouth prefered) if full
3) blow over top.
4) observe similar type of sound
5) extrapolate.

"'Curly Q. Links'" <motsco__@interbaun.com> wrote in message
news:44949C92.3A756F32@interbaun.com...
> aulttim wrote:
>>
>> When driving at highway speeds, our '06 Odyssey produces a wierd sonic
>> "thumping" sensation when the sliding door windows down (even just
>> partly, in my experience) while the drv/pass windows are up? Lowering
>> the front windows or raising the sliding door windows makes the
>> thumping go stop. Anyone else notice this?
>
> --------------------------------------
>
> I think the technical term is 'POP BOTTLE EFFECT' and it happens on LOTS
> of vehicles that are fairly air-tight.
>
> 'Curly'

Actually, the *technical* term is "aeolian oscillation" but your term makes
it clearer. We've fielded the same question several times on several cars,
usually involving the driver window. It essentially turns the passenger
compartment into a big whistle.

Mike

As you've found out, you just have to experiment. On my 4-door '04 Accord,
lowering the driver's window by itself is fine. Lower also the front
passenger window and the thumping occurs. But if I lower the rear right
passenger window instead of the front passenger window, along with the
driver's window, the effect stops.

Yes! I have an '06 Odyssey, and whenever my kids have those windows down,
it's deafening, and I feel like my head will explode from the thumping it
makes. It's like going deaf and it also actually "hurts" so those windows
NEVER come down on the highway, especially!

aulttim wrote:
>When driving at highway speeds, our '06 Odyssey produces a wierd sonic
>"thumping" sensation when the sliding door windows down (even just
>partly, in my experience) while the drv/pass windows are up? Lowering
>the front windows or raising the sliding door windows makes the
>thumping go stop. Anyone else notice this?

Exactly! The sensation is painful, and sometimes it can be nauseating.
Lowering either front window (or locking the rear from being lowered)
is the only solution it seems.

I discovered this annoying characteristic with the '06 Odyssey after
trading in an '05. A feature of the '05 is the tilt-out rear windows
which provide air flow through the van. I did not notice the thumping
in the previous model--it is possibly opening the rear windows was the
reason.

Honda issued a TSB against the '06 Odyssey regarding a high-pitched
whistle heard from the front of the van at highway speeds (a correction
kit is available and owners can contact a dealership to have this
problem fixed under warranty). I am curious if Honda has issued a TSB
regarding the thumping phenomenon--a.k.a., aeolian oscillation; "pop
bottle effect"; etc--common to the '06 Odyssey model.

Tim.

On 19 Jun 2006 07:33:39 -0700, "aulttim" <aulttim@gmail.com> wrote:

>Exactly! The sensation is painful, and sometimes it can be nauseating.
>Lowering either front window (or locking the rear from being lowered)
>is the only solution it seems.
>
>I discovered this annoying characteristic with the '06 Odyssey after
>trading in an '05. A feature of the '05 is the tilt-out rear windows
>which provide air flow through the van. I did not notice the thumping
>in the previous model--it is possibly opening the rear windows was the
>reason.
>
>Honda issued a TSB against the '06 Odyssey regarding a high-pitched
>whistle heard from the front of the van at highway speeds (a correction
>kit is available and owners can contact a dealership to have this
>problem fixed under warranty). I am curious if Honda has issued a TSB
>regarding the thumping phenomenon--a.k.a., aeolian oscillation; "pop
>bottle effect"; etc--common to the '06 Odyssey model.

its hardly a new or unknown phenominan. What would you have them do to
fit it? replace the windows with the quarterlights previously
installed?

>
>Tim.

"aulttim" <aulttim@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1150580663.051944.162340@r2g2000cwb.googlegro ups.com...
> When driving at highway speeds, our '06 Odyssey produces a wierd sonic
> "thumping" sensation when the sliding door windows down (even just
> partly, in my experience) while the drv/pass windows are up? Lowering
> the front windows or raising the sliding door windows makes the
> thumping go stop. Anyone else notice this?
>
I was told there was a sound when the engine went from 3-6 cylinder
operation or reverse. I was also told that the radio automatically emitted
white noise to eliminate that sound.

actually, that's not such an unreasonable suggestion. since the rear
windows do not tilt out in the '06, the air gets stuff for third row
passengers. cracking either rear tilt-out window lt'd likely reduce or
eliminate the pop bottle effect when a passenger window is lowered. i'd
say those are two good reasons to add the rear tilt-out windows back as
a feature of succeeding models.

i must admit i've entertained the idea of.. um.. "restoring" the
feature. the dimensions of the rear window glass & frame are different
between model years, so a retrofit of the '05 system into an '06/'07 is
not an option. a cursory search aftermarket kits of this sort didn't
result in any acceptable solutions. maybe a vent or moonroof might be
effective.