> I need a dependable car which I will keep for around 6 years, and of
course
> residual value is important.

Then get a 2004. Purchasing a 2003 at this time of year is a false saving.
I think that the Corolla is superior to the Civic. My wife got a 2004 1
month ago. It has much more zest than previous generation. It is actually
fun-to-drive. Comfy and reasonnably quiet. Good fit and finish. On the
minus side, engine is a bit rough at high rpm and steering position is too
high to my taste.