Well, the TSX is an all around better car. It is more fun to drive, has more room, and looks nicer. They will last about the same, and they get about the same mileage, so it is up to you, although convertible is naturally higher maintenance, since there are more things that can break. I actually am trying to convince my dad to get a TSX as his next car, since he is currently shopping for one.































Don't get me wrong, the Beetle is a nice car, but I would personally enjoy being able to comfortably carry more people, and have a nicer interior.































Last, don't forget that overall, car choice is an opinion. If you really like convertible Beetles, go for it, you only live once.