well one is a 2 door and one is a 4 door. thats a big difference, but if you dont have a preference as far as the amount of doors then i would go for the honda.better gas mileage, better looks (in my opinion), better quality, and better reliability. my car has both xenons and navigation (325i) and i love those options and feel like i couldnt live without them. but if i had to choose, i would rather have xenons than the nav, but other than that reason I'd go for the honda all the way