The Acura TL is actually based on the V6 Honda Accord EX. It doesn't even fall in the same category as the Civic. As nice as the civic seems, it's still an econocar. The TL is an upgraded V6 Accord. No comparison. The TL will be a better all-around car- as it's price tag would suggest. Someone mentioned the TL being a better value as a used vehicle. It would appear that way initially until you try to resell it yourself. Give it 2 years and look at how much more the TL depreciates. You can almost sell the Civic for what you paid for it in the same amount of time. Is the Civic overrated? Yes but who cares? It's still a better investment.I personally like the TLs performance, features, and look, but if you buy one used, expect to have to replace the tranny on pre-2004 TLs. There is a recall on them so Honda/Acura will replace the tranny for you,but it's the same tranny that you already have (with no real changes) so expect it to go out again. Also, being a premium car, Acura recommends premium unleaded fuel for it as well.