Gary wrote:
> "jim beam" <spamvortex@bad.example.net> wrote in message
> news:9P6dnWL_mKDApU_bnZ2dnUVZ_gednZ2d@speakeasy.ne t...
>> Gary wrote:
>
>> 1. please learn to cross post so all answers are read by all groups.
>> 2. "rusted" as in rusted through so it's leaking, or "rusted" so that
>> it's just got surface rust on it? if the latter, just smear some grease
>> on it and forget about it.
>
>
> The mechanic claims its rusted and said he was afraid to open the cap to
> drain it. Since two different shops said this was a problem I am concerned.

did you ask a leading question or did they both come out with this
recommendation spontaneously and independently?


> Is it normal for rust to appear on the oil pan?
>
>
not unless you scrape it when you park or your mechanic is in the habit
of jacking the vehicle up by it.

bottom line, if it /is/ rusted badly enough, sure, it needs to be
replaced. however, the probability is low. and frankly, if the oil
pan's rusted through, i doubt there's much else of the car left given
that the pan is so thick and the body is so thin.

post a pic [say tinypic.com] if you want further opinion.