Chris Lamb wrote:
>
> Of those 4 vehicles, and understanding my determinants, and hopefully
> YOU knowing a whole lot more about these vehicles than I do, which
> would you buy and why?

Nissan Versa has a larger engine than its competitors so it may be able
to tow your boat and still provide decent mpg.

Element is not especially fuel efficient - a 2007 Camry delivers better
mpg and is a much safer vehicle; Camry can tow 1000 lb.

If you drive in town the new tiny cars offer some advantages. If you
drive on the highway you should try to verify that the tiny cars will
actually deliver the rated mpg and you should test drive them to see if
you are satisfied with their highway performance.

I'd probably buy a used Camry or Accord or Corolla rather than a new
Fit, Yaris or Versa if I needed a commuter car (but I need highway
performance/safety for my commute).